Coinbase Advanced Trade cuts fees from 1.49% to 0.40-0.60% using limit orders — same account, no signup needed. Complete guide to order types, the interface, and when to use it.
The Two Giants of Bitcoin Exchanges
Coinbase and Kraken are the two most trusted Bitcoin exchanges in the United States and among the top exchanges globally. Both have been operating for over a decade, neither has been hacked, and both offer serious infrastructure for buying and holding Bitcoin.
But they serve different types of users and have different strengths. Here is an honest comparison.
Quick Comparison
| Feature | Coinbase | Kraken |
|---|---|---|
| Founded | 2012 | 2011 |
| Publicly traded | Yes (NASDAQ: COIN) | No (privately held) |
| Maker/taker fees | 0.40% / 0.60% | 0.16% / 0.26% |
| Simple buy fee | Up to 1.5% | Up to 1.5% |
| Supported countries | 100+ | 190+ |
| Security track record | Never hacked | Never hacked |
| Lightning withdrawals | Yes | Yes |
| Proof of reserves | Yes | Yes (transparent) |
| Customer support | Email, chat | 24/7 live support |
| Mobile app | Excellent | Good |
| Assets supported | 200+ | 300+ |
Fees: Kraken Wins
This is the biggest difference and the one that matters most for active buyers.
Kraken's maker/taker fees start at 0.16%/0.26% — roughly half of Coinbase's 0.40%/0.60%. For a $10,000 Bitcoin purchase:
- Kraken: ~$26 in fees
- Coinbase Advanced: ~$60 in fees
- Coinbase Simple Buy: up to ~$150 in fees
Over a year of regular purchases, this adds up significantly. If you are cost-conscious, Kraken saves you real money.
Winner: Kraken — Meaningfully lower fees across the board.
User Experience: Coinbase Wins
Coinbase has invested heavily in design and onboarding. The mobile app is polished, intuitive, and well-organized. Setting up an account, linking a bank, and making a first purchase is genuinely easy.
Kraken's experience has improved dramatically but still lags Coinbase in polish. The mobile app is functional but less refined. The web interface for Kraken Pro can feel cluttered compared to Coinbase Advanced.
For someone buying Bitcoin for the first time, Coinbase is the smoother experience.
Winner: Coinbase — Better design, easier onboarding, more intuitive.
Security: Tie
Both exchanges have impeccable security records:
- Coinbase: Never hacked. Publicly traded (subject to SEC oversight and audits). Stores 98% of customer funds in cold storage. FDIC-insured USD deposits up to $250,000.
- Kraken: Never hacked. Proof-of-reserves audits published regularly. Among the first exchanges to implement proof of reserves. Strong internal security culture.
Coinbase has the edge on regulatory transparency (public company disclosures), while Kraken has the edge on proof-of-reserves transparency. Both are top-tier.
Winner: Tie — Both are excellent. Different strengths in transparency.
Withdrawal Options: Kraken Has a Slight Edge
Both exchanges support withdrawing Bitcoin to your own wallet, which is the most important feature.
- Coinbase: On-chain withdrawals, Lightning Network support, instant sends to other Coinbase users. Network fees are passed through at cost.
- Kraken: On-chain withdrawals, Lightning Network support. Competitive withdrawal fees. Slightly faster processing in our experience.
Both support Lightning, which means you can withdraw small amounts instantly and for near-zero cost.
Winner: Slight edge to Kraken — Competitive fees and reliable processing.
Asset Selection: Depends on What You Want
If you are Bitcoin-only, this does not matter — both list Bitcoin.
If you also want other assets:
- Coinbase: 200+ assets. More selective about listings (though less so than before).
- Kraken: 300+ assets. Broad selection including many assets not on Coinbase.
For Bitcoin-only buyers, consider River or Swan Bitcoin instead — they eliminate altcoin distractions entirely.
Winner: Draw — Both have Bitcoin. Kraken has more altcoins if you care.
Customer Support: Kraken Wins
Kraken offers 24/7 live customer support — you can actually talk to a human at any time. This is rare in the exchange world and genuinely valuable when you have an issue.
Coinbase has historically had poor customer support, though they have invested in improvement. Support is available via email and chat, but response times can still be slow during high-volume periods.
Winner: Kraken — 24/7 live support is a meaningful advantage.
Regulatory Status: Coinbase Wins
Coinbase is publicly traded on NASDAQ (ticker: COIN), which means:
- Quarterly financial disclosures
- SEC oversight
- Independent audits
- Public board of directors
This level of transparency is unmatched by any other exchange. If the exchange fails, you have more legal recourse and visibility into what happened.
Kraken is privately held and well-regulated, but does not have the same level of public financial disclosure.
Winner: Coinbase — Public company transparency is a real advantage.
Staking and Earn Programs: Both Offer
Both exchanges offer staking rewards on proof-of-stake assets (not relevant for Bitcoin specifically). Neither offers interest on Bitcoin holdings — and you should be skeptical of any platform that does.
Winner: Draw — Not relevant for Bitcoin buyers.
Who Should Use Coinbase?
- First-time Bitcoin buyers who want the smoothest onboarding
- US investors who value publicly traded, SEC-regulated infrastructure
- Casual buyers who purchase occasionally and value convenience over fees
- Users who already have a Coinbase account — switching cost is real
Who Should Use Kraken?
- Regular buyers who want to minimize fees over time
- International users — Kraken operates in more countries
- Users who value customer support — 24/7 live support matters
- Fee-conscious accumulators who buy frequently (DCA buyers)
The Third Option: Use Both
Many experienced Bitcoin buyers use both:
- Coinbase for the polished mobile app and quick occasional purchases
- Kraken for larger purchases where the fee savings justify the slightly less polished experience
And then they withdraw to cold storage either way — because the exchange is where you buy, not where you hold.
Our Recommendation
If you are buying Bitcoin for the first time: Start with Coinbase. The experience is smoother and the learning curve is gentler.
If you are buying regularly and care about fees: Use Kraken. The 0.16% maker fee will save you hundreds or thousands per year compared to Coinbase.
If you want Bitcoin-only simplicity: Skip both and use River or Swan Bitcoin.
No matter which exchange you choose: withdraw your Bitcoin to a hardware wallet. Our cold storage comparison will help you pick the right one.
Compare all exchanges: Exchange Directory → Secure your Bitcoin after buying: Cold Storage Devices →